Posted by: Jerry Garrett | August 26, 2012

Florida Man Presses His Claim for #1 Cunningham Corvette

The Corvette supposedly raced at Le Mans in 1960 by Briggs Cunningham was shown privately Aug. 23. (Courtesy of

Dan Mathis Jr., the Florida man who claims ownership of the missing #1 Cunningham Le Mans Corvette, said early Sunday he still does not know where the Corvette is.

Dan Mathis Jr. photo of local and state police officials outside the home and garage of the Miller family in Carlisle, Pa.

Mr. Mathis said he had been in Carlisle, Pa., where the car was unveiled Thursday night (August 23) at a private showing in connection the Corvettes at Carlisle car show. (For a photo gallery of the Corvette, go to this page at the site.) The event was organized by Lance Miller, a noted Corvette collector, who claimed he owned the car briefly after it was discovered in June, in a St. Petersburg, Fla., warehouse.

Mr. Miller contacted me early Sunday via email, and wrote: “As you may, or may not know, I’ve been swamped do to holding one of our largest events of the season – Corvettes at Carlisle. Hence I haven’t had an opportunity to keep up with my email, phone calls and etc. Once the dust settles I’ll have more time to focus. You were the first to contact me regarding this issue at hand, hence my previous email to you. I will provide a statement in the near future. As you are aware I only owned the vehicle for 2 days and sold it to the current owner who asked to remain anonymous, I’m respecting his wishes.”

Mr. Mathis said he would continue to press his claim.

“We tried to retrieve the car, they are currently hiding it from law enforcement,” Mr. Mathis said. He said he was in contact with Det. Eric Dale of the Carlisle, Pa., police department, the Cumberland County, Pa., district attorney and the Pennsylvania State Police. Det. Dale told me, “No comment” when I contacted him Monday about the matter.

Copy of Corvette title. (Courtesy of Dan Mathis Jr.)

“I’ll be back there Monday to continue to try and locate the car,” Mr. Mathis told me in a telephone interview. He said he had presented his Certificate of Title from the State of Florida, showing his ownership of the car, to Mr. Miller and his associate Kevin Mackay, of Corvette Repair, Inc.

“Lance Miller and Kevin Mackay were previously contacted by sources inquiring about the true ownership of the car, inquiring about the title for the car, and inquiring [about] the previous transactions involving the car,” Mr. Mathis wrote to me. “They were also informed that there was an owner of record in Florida. After learning this new information, Lance and Kevin opted not to take the reasonable and prudent route to legitimize this famous car. Instead they took route of deception and theft.”

When the long-lost, long sought-after Corvette, raced by noted sportsman Briggs Cunningham at Le Mans in 1960, finally broke cover last month, Mr. Miller said little was known about its whereabouts since being sold at a Chevrolet dealership after the Cunningham team returned home from America.

It was discovered in a large warehouse in St. Petersburg, Fla., by Rick Carr. Mr. Carr said the warehouse was one of two owned by his late father, Richard W. Carr, who had died in 2010 at age 80. A retired Florida judge, Richard W. Carr had resigned from the bench in 1992 after being censured by the Florida Supreme Court for uttering a racial epithet in his courtroom.

Mr. Mathis said his father Dan Mathis Sr., who died in 1993, had purchased the car in the mid-1970s from a man named Jerry Moore, of Tampa. He said his father did some bodywork on the car, painted it a rather unique cherry chocolate color, and proceeded to campaign it at various central Florida drag strips. “A black man drag racing in central Florida was a rare sight, in those times,” Mr. Mathis added.

“Does anyone wonder who did the drag car modifications and alterations? Who painted the car?” Mr. Mathis said to me. “These questions should have been answered during the presentation of the history of the car, instead of kept secret. The answer to the above questions? The owner of the car, Dan Mathis Sr.”

Mr. Mathis said the car was stolen in the mid-1970s, and “disappeared for 35 years,” he said. “My dad died, not knowing what ever happened to his beloved race car.” Mr. Mathis offered to provide photos of his father with the car, but said efforts to do so were being complicated by Hurricane Isaac’s imminent arrival in the Tampa area, by the fact the photos are “in possession of my 90-year-old grandma, and she’s having a little difficulty locating them,” he added. “I can help her when I can get home.”

Mr. Mathis said he is a retired Florida law enforcement officer.

How the Corvette passed from the possession of the Mathis family, to the judge’s warehouse, is not known. “Great question,” Mr. Mathis said.

Jerry Garrett

August 26, 2012



  1. […] Sr., Lance Miller « Almost Famous: Lindbergh’s Aviation Nemesis Charles Levine Florida Man Presses His Claim for #1 Cunningham Corvette […]

  2. Garret this case is all based on fraud.
    First title is a new titled issued last week.
    second Title shows “WHITE” as color.
    Mathis claims his dad painted the car this color. If he knew that based on the dte of title why did he not have that as the color??? He only found out the color and customization after pictures posted on internet.
    Lastly, Google his name and see what you get …

  3. […] Posted in Auto Racing, Automobiles, Automobilia, Cars, Classic Cars, Collectible Cars, Transportation | Tags: #1 Cunningham Corvette, 24 Hours of Le Mans, Briggs Cunningham, Carlisle Police Department, Chevrolet Corvette, Cumberland County District Attorney, Dan Mathis Jr., Lance Miller « Florida Man Presses His Claim for #1 Cunningham Corvette […]

  4. I’m sure since his father was racing the car in the ’70’s that Mr. Mathis Jr. has some pictures of Mr. Mathis,Sr. with the car in question, yes?

    • Mr. Mathis has been asked if he has such photos, and told they will be published on this blog when and if he supplies them.

  5. I would like to think that Mr. Mathis, Jr., can produce original photos of his father, Mr. Mathis, Sr., and this race car from the ’70’s, yes? Maybe a program from a drag strip with his name and a photo of the car in question?

    • Again, Mr. Mathis has been asked to supply such items. They will be published here if we receive them.

  6. That car was never stolen. It was probably sold and never retitled. Which happens all the time. Where is the police report???? How come this never surfaced that the car was stolen, if there was a police report???? This car belong to his dead dad not him, so how did it get put in his name (It was stolen before the old guy died). Come on think a little here.

    • I am only reporting what the various parties involved in this are doing. Mr. Mathis was pressing his claim before it came to my attention. I will report the outcome of this, regardless of where the facts lead. I don’t, as they say, have a dog in this hunt.

    • Speculating of couse, but Lou hit the nail on the head. Car probably traded hands as a race car/project back in the day on a handshake and napkin bill of sale. Now that the public knows what it is, anyone who can grab for it is doing so.

  7. Jerry, the rights to the car are now up for sale to the highest bidder!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: